Mike Livingston Wins 3.3 Million Against State For Teenagers Killed When Maui Cliff Collapses
Karen Dougher mourns the death of her son, James Makekau, and friend Denise Callo at the Lahaina pali overlook where they were killed. GARY KUBOTA / 2005
A dangerous scenic Maui overlook remains open despite a $3.2 million court decision that found the state liable for the death of a 16-year-old in a car that plunged off the cliff, according to the teenager's mother.
"It has not been blocked," Karen "Kalena" Dougher said Thursday. "I don't understand that at all. They should close it off permanently so no other family has to go through what I and my daughter went through and still go through."
Maui Circuit Judge Joseph Cardoza found the state responsible Wednesday for the hazardous lookout off Honoapiilani Highway and awarded family members of the late James Makekau and Denise Callo $3,278,833.
In his 200-page decision, Cardoza found the state "solely and wholly" liable for the deaths.
Makekau was riding with Callo, 34, on April 13, 2005, when the car Callo was driving made a turn on the overlook next to the Lahaina pali and plunged 150 feet down a cliff. Both were killed.
Tiffany Romena was in the front seat, and her 3-month-old daughter, Kaila Kuulei Callo, was in a rear car seat. Both survived the accident, and rescuers found the infant crying and relatively unharmed in the back of the car.
Joshua Wisch, a spokesman for the state attorney general, said his office was disappointed with the court's decision.
"The state presented substantial evidence at trial to show that it was not at fault," Wisch said. "The official police investigation concluded the driver was almost three times over the blood alcohol legal limit, had been smoking marijuana with the passengers, and actually drove off the cliff."
A medical examiner at the time found Callo had a blood-alcohol level of 0.27 percent.
Wisch said the state has 30 days to decide whether to appeal.
Attorney Michael Livingston, representing the Dougher family, said Cardoza found that with or without the use of alcohol and marijuana, those in the vehicle would have fallen over the cliff because the overlook was hazardous and the earth beneath the vehicle was unstable and had buckled.
"That kind of pulled the vehicle over the edge," Livingston said. "He found ultimately that it (marijuana and alcohol) did not contribute to the tragedy."
Attorneys on behalf of the Makekau and Callo families alleged the overlook was left open to the public, had no guardrail, and signs were never installed warning of the dangers.
Cardoza awarded $725,000 to the estate of Denise Callo; $400,000 to her mother, Annette Callo; and $250,000 to Romena. Denise Callo was the aunt of Romena's baby.
Cardoza awarded the estate of James Makekau $303,833 in economic damages and $800,000 in noneconomic damages, and awarded $400,000 each to Dougher and to the estate of Makekau's late father, Robert Makekau.
Dougher said last week was the seventh anniversary of her son's death, and she revisited the site for the first time in seven years, as the court decision neared.
"I feel justice has prevailed. Yet, it's so hard to describe what that feels like. There's nothing that can compensate for the loss."
She was on a spur-of-the-moment road trip to Hana when she got the call Wednesday from Livingston about the ruling.
"For seven years I didn't see the beauty in our islands anymore, and in life," she said Thursday. "The island is beautiful because I can let my son rest. That's what it's about: finding peace and beauty in life again."
"It's very bittersweet," she said. "There's nothing that can bring him back."
Dougher recalled a visit last year with Tiffany Romena's daughter, Kyla, the infant who survived.
"It was a miracle to be able to hold her," Dougher said. "She's 7. She's gorgeous. Gorgeous."
contact Michael Livingston
Our Web site provides general information to the public and is not intended as legal advice in any particular situation or to any specific individual. Before relying upon the contents in our Web site regarding a particular legal problem or situation, you should first obtain professional consultation. There can be no attorney and client relationship between our firm and any individual, nor any duty to act by our attorneys, until there is a written retainer agreement signed by both client and attorney.